Custom POI Download - Police Speed Traps (V5.2)(120406)

Feedback for our road information and food recommendation POIs

Moderators: wwloon, alharis299, Moderators, Regional Mappers

Forum rules
1. Be nice to each other and respect the moderators. Post in normal font size, color and weight. Follow Nettiquette
2. NO out of topic. This forum is strictly for feedback to our custom POIs
3. NO posting of data copied from other source especially malsingmaps
4. NO abuse, profanity and insults
5. NO spamming, cross posting and opening of duplicate topics
6. NO post/link to warez, cracks, serials or illegally obtained copyrighted content
7. Each message posted is owned by and is the opinion of the original poster. Neither mfm nor its owner or moderators are legally responsible for anything posted on the forum
mtbseng
Posts: 18
Joined: Fri Oct 03, 2008 9:51 am

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps

Postby mtbseng » Sun Feb 08, 2009 2:25 pm

mtbseng wrote:stratman2,
Wanna feedback that the "coastal highway" leading from Batu Uban to Bayan lepas FTZ area is 70km/h limit. The speed trap alert is displayed 80km/h limit.

seng

seng, help bro stratman by giving the coordinates lah; and don't assume everyone knows you're talking about some place in Penang.

Anyway the location is N5.34578 E100.30872 or thereabouts. - tympg


Sorry. i spent sometime to look into the alert and this is what i found out.

1. I saw the speed alert is already there, indicating 70km/h. Refer to Speed_feedback70kmh.jpg. But i think the speed limit is only one sided. Should be both side of Bayan Lepas express way.

2. I tried my best to mark the location which should be only 70km/h from batu uban to Queensbay Mall using way point tool. pls. refer to gdb file attach which contains 2 new waypoints.

3. I run a simulation mode (since i can work on GPS while driving with my old manual car), i captured 2 screen shots showing the alert "80km/h Speed Trap Ahead". May be just the wording is wrong.

hope this helps.
mtbseng
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

User avatar
tympg
Senior Mapper
Posts: 1586
Joined: Mon Sep 15, 2008 11:01 am
Location: Penang

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps

Postby tympg » Sun Feb 08, 2009 5:20 pm

mtbseng,

The 70km/h you saw is not really a Custom POI speed alert. It is the label of the Yellow-and-Black-stripes polygon which I put into the map. This polygon of course does not trigger any alert as such. It looks one-sided because the City Park (green) polygon has buried the other side.

mtbseng wrote:Sorry. i spent sometime to look into the alert and this is what i found out.

1. I saw the speed alert is already there, indicating 70km/h. Refer to Speed_feedback70kmh.jpg. But i think the speed limit is only one sided. Should be both side of Bayan Lepas express way.
Garmin nüvi 2575R; Garmin eTrex Vista HCx; Android 5.0.1 Phone

User avatar
stratman2
Valued Contributor
Posts: 366
Joined: Fri Oct 10, 2008 4:31 am
Location: P. Jaya with Garmin Nuvi 310, eTrex Vista HCx and HTC Incredible S + PapaGo X5 :-)
Contact:

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps

Postby stratman2 » Mon Feb 09, 2009 9:39 pm

To those looking for the latest MFM Speed Trap cPOI, download it here:

viewtopic.php?f=24&t=986&p=14812#p14812


:tq:
cheers,

Stratman II

User avatar
msports
Polygon Mapper
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2008 9:22 pm
Location: Kajang, Pantai Hillpark, KL, Bangi, Putrajaya, Kota Tinggi

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps

Postby msports » Mon Feb 16, 2009 5:57 pm

stratman2 wrote:To those looking for the latest MFM Speed Trap cPOI, download it here:
viewtopic.php?f=24&t=986&p=14812#p1481
:tq:


Bro Stratman2! :D

I've some feedback for improvement if it is possible... i'm confuse with some of the speed alerts especially when it is located at multi level roads/expressways/intersections/overhead ramps. On which road direction is actually the speeds traps always in operation because the alarm always trigger no matter from wherever you are. By right it is usually located at certain route only. For example, when we joint in the expressway from Kajang tol toward KL intersection, the alarm was triggered, by right the speed trap is on the KL-SBN North/South E2 under the bridge, and not at the intersection road above (if I'm not mistaken). :-k
I think, there are few more locations having the same problem; eg. Persiaran Utara/Persiaran Timur (N2 57.47 E101 42.80) at Putrajaya, and speed trap alert at E20 (Putrajaya-KL expressway) near Bkt Jalil. I believe the speed trap is for the road underneath the E20 and not on E20 because the speed limit tell 90km/h whereby speed limit on E20 for that area is 80km/h and no hiding area for PDRM to enforce speed trap, except via fixed speed camera.
It is very much appreciated if false alert(s) like this can be eliminated. It's will be good if the T&G reload lane one-way alert system can be apply here too.

long live bro stratman2! :peace:
Cheers!
Last edited by msports on Tue Feb 17, 2009 11:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
msports/// : nuvi710, nuvi255W, GMXT on 5800 & N97, PAPAGO X7 (R6600), latest on Nuvi3790 & always on mfm

User avatar
stratman2
Valued Contributor
Posts: 366
Joined: Fri Oct 10, 2008 4:31 am
Location: P. Jaya with Garmin Nuvi 310, eTrex Vista HCx and HTC Incredible S + PapaGo X5 :-)
Contact:

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps

Postby stratman2 » Tue Feb 17, 2009 8:11 pm

msports wrote:
Bro Stratman2! :D

I've some feedback for improvement if it is possible... i'm confuse with some of the speed alerts especially when it is located at multi level roads/expressways/intersections/overhead ramps. On which road direction is actually the speeds traps always in operation because the alarm always trigger no matter from wherever you are. By right it is usually located at certain route only. For example, when we joint in the expressway from Kajang tol toward KL intersection, the alarm was triggered, by right the speed trap is on the KL-SBN North/South E2 under the bridge, and not at the intersection road above (if I'm not mistaken). :-k


This is unfortunately a peculiar Garmin quirk. I've checked the waypoint and it's placed exactly on the road (Psn Utara) and not at the intersection. Perhaps the waypoint is too close in proximity with the intersection therefore Garmin interprets this as a valid routable alert. I'm not sure whether this is attributed to the MFM map or your GPS device.

There are other possible causes - like misalignment of your Garmin device in relation to the map for instance. I had experienced a problem last month with my Nuvi 310 (I was using MFM v1.40) - the true location of my home (@ 5 meters' accuracy) was not reflected on my GPS screen. I did a reset to erase the satellite ephemeris and almanac data and all was fine after that.
:mrgreen:


I think, there are few more locations having the same problem; eg. Persiaran Utara/Persiaran Timur (N2 57.47 E101 42.80) at Putrajaya, and speed trap alert at E20 (Putrajaya-KL expressway) near Bkt Jalil. I believe the speed trap is for the road underneath the E20 and not on E20 because the speed limit tell 90km/h whereby speed limit on E20 for that area is 80km/h and no hiding area for PDRM to enforce speed trap, except via speed camera.


Brother Msports, can you verify this for certain or are you making personal assumptions? :thumbsup:

It is very much appreciated if false alert(s) like this can be eliminated. It's will be good if the T&G reload lane one-way alert system can be apply here too.


The TnG alerting system is not speed dependent. Therefore I can place one trigger waypoint for the particular ramp or lane leading to the toll plazas. Non-tour guide POIs are bi-directional in nature - they will alert you from either direction as long as you are approaching the POI on the designated route. Tour Guide POIs, OTOH will alert you so long you are within the radius, even though you are not heading towards the POI but driving parallel with the POI.

Speed trap POIs are speed-dependent. Therefore it's much easier for maintenance of such POIs to have only one trigger point with a single wide, 1km radius than multiple 10-meter radius POIs scattered along the route. You can also have only one trigger point, but what's the use if you exceed the speed warning parameter after you've passed that single trigger point? :nutz:

At the moment I have not been able to establish exactly how non-Tour Guide POis work when they are placed close to multi-level intersections and ramps. But I do know they will trigger in the case of two lanes sited on top of one another - for example, the Sprint highway nearing Kg Kerinchi, KL.

:tq:
cheers,

Stratman II

User avatar
msports
Polygon Mapper
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2008 9:22 pm
Location: Kajang, Pantai Hillpark, KL, Bangi, Putrajaya, Kota Tinggi

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps

Postby msports » Wed Feb 18, 2009 12:01 am

msports wrote:
Sorry for my ignorance bro! have no idea how it's work or configured... anyway thanks!


Today (20Feb) I've relised there is 2 speed alert on E20. 1st one is near and approaching Bkit Jalil from Putrajaya. The speed limit is 80km/h.
2nd speed trap was located close to the 1st one, near the stadium, but the speed limit was 90km/h. therefore the 2nd one I assume was on Jln Barat underneath E20 because the speed limit on E20 at that areas is 80km/h.

Somebody please clarify!


(sorry my bad english)
msports/// : nuvi710, nuvi255W, GMXT on 5800 & N97, PAPAGO X7 (R6600), latest on Nuvi3790 & always on mfm

soulquarianz
Posts: 12
Joined: Wed Nov 12, 2008 4:56 pm

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps (v2)

Postby soulquarianz » Thu Feb 26, 2009 9:07 am

Hi Stratman, u know why i still have error whenever using your POI? my GMXT will crash specially in Putrajaya...

below are the errlog from my gmxt

Kaiser
PocketPC 240 x 320

[2/26/09 7:32:07 40748KB 5.00.20wp]
Read Access violation at data address 0x03D0E3C0.
Program address 0x001714B4 in background thread NULL (GfxFieldWindowProc)
[2/26/09 7:32:07 40748KB 5.00.20wp]
CALL STACK:
0x03F650AC
0x1618544C
0x16185C40
0x16185F8C
0x160BEF7C
0x03F8A060
0x03F9049C
0x80017100
0x800446AC
0x8001B1F4
0x80017018
0x161714B4
0x16171B0C
0x16255EBC
0x16254220
0x16158D28
0x16158DD8
0x16257AA0
0x16251650
0x16253BE0
0x160D369C
0x160BDB3C
0x160BE170

[2/26/09 7:33:05 41084KB 5.00.20wp]
Read Access violation at data address 0x05D0E3C0.
Program address 0x001714B4 in background thread NULL (GfxFieldWindowProc)
[2/26/09 7:33:05 41084KB 5.00.20wp]
CALL STACK:
0x03F650AC
0x1618544C
0x16185C40
0x16185F8C
0x160BEF7C
0x03F8A060
0x03F9049C
0x80017100
0x800446AC
0x8001B1F4
0x80017018
0x161714B4
0x16171B0C
0x16255EBC
0x16254220
0x16158D28
0x16158DD8
0x16257AA0
0x16251650
0x16253BE0
0x160D369C
0x160BDB3C
0x160BE170

[2/26/09 7:37:09 40804KB 5.00.20wp]
Read Access violation at data address 0xFDD0E3C0.
Program address 0x001714B4 in background thread NULL (GfxFieldWindowProc)
[2/26/09 7:37:09 40804KB 5.00.20wp]
CALL STACK:
0x03F650AC
0x1618544C
0x16185C40
0x16185F8C
0x160BEF7C
0x03F8A060
0x03F9049C
0x80017100
0x800446AC
0x8001B1F4
0x80017018
0x161714B4
0x16171B0C
0x16255EBC
0x16254220
0x16158D28
0x16158DD8
0x16257AA0
0x16251650
0x16253BE0
0x160D369C
0x160BDB3C
0x160BE170
Kaiser with GMXT

User avatar
FauSham
Posts: 104
Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2008 10:13 pm
Location: Kelantan [Legend Cx / Nuvi 200(Damage) / Nuvi 760 / Nuvi 265W(New)]
Contact:

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps (v2)

Postby FauSham » Thu Feb 26, 2009 10:30 am

Stratman,

1.In School alert: Can u change "School zone comming up ahead" with "Dong,dong.... warning school zone area."
FauSham @ Malaysia & Singapore Free Maps - MalFreeMaps
AMATEUR RADIO CALLSIGN: 9W2WFN

User avatar
stratman2
Valued Contributor
Posts: 366
Joined: Fri Oct 10, 2008 4:31 am
Location: P. Jaya with Garmin Nuvi 310, eTrex Vista HCx and HTC Incredible S + PapaGo X5 :-)
Contact:

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps

Postby stratman2 » Thu Feb 26, 2009 1:46 pm

msports wrote:
msports wrote:
Sorry for my ignorance bro! have no idea how it's work or configured... anyway thanks!


Today (20Feb) I've relised there is 2 speed alert on E20. 1st one is near and approaching Bkit Jalil from Putrajaya. The speed limit is 80km/h.
2nd speed trap was located close to the 1st one, near the stadium, but the speed limit was 90km/h. therefore the 2nd one I assume was on Jln Barat underneath E20 because the speed limit on E20 at that areas is 80km/h.

Somebody please clarify!


(sorry my bad english)



Hi Brother Msports,


As I mentioned in my first posting of the Speed Trap cPOI, the speed alert POIs were based on old data, some may be out of date or inaccurate. You would know better than I do because you ply along those roads daily (I haven't driven there for more than 2 years, I think).

Would you kindly point out the correct speed limits for those stretches? :tq:
cheers,

Stratman II

User avatar
stratman2
Valued Contributor
Posts: 366
Joined: Fri Oct 10, 2008 4:31 am
Location: P. Jaya with Garmin Nuvi 310, eTrex Vista HCx and HTC Incredible S + PapaGo X5 :-)
Contact:

Re: Custom POI download - Police Speed Traps (v2)

Postby stratman2 » Thu Feb 26, 2009 1:49 pm

FauSham wrote:Stratman,

1.In School alert: Can u change "School zone comming up ahead" with "Dong,dong.... warning school zone area."



Err...bro FauSham, do you mean you literally want that lady to say "Dong, dong"? :mrgreen: It can be done easily, hehe... :D
cheers,

Stratman II


Return to “MFM Custom POI Feedback”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 21 guests